Adam Sheafe, an Arizona man accused of murdering and crucifying Pastor William Schonemann, has requested the death penalty to expedite the legal process. Representing himself, Sheafe asked a judge last week to allow a guilty plea to quickly conclude the case, citing delays in the justice system.
Details of the Crime and Legal Proceedings
Sheafe, 51, is charged with the April 2025 murder of Schonemann, 76, the pastor of New River Bible Chapel. Authorities reported that Schonemann was found dead with his arms spread apart and hands pinned to a wall. After the killing, Sheafe mutilated the pastor’s body and placed a crown of thorns on his head. Sheafe fully confessed to the crime before being indicted and has consistently admitted guilt, denying any innocence.
The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office opposed Sheafe’s initial petition to plead no contest, leading him to offer a guilty plea instead. A judge has scheduled a hearing to confirm the plea is made voluntarily before proceeding to sentencing.
Sheafe’s Motivation and Statements
Sheafe told the court that the murder was part of a broader plot he called “Operation First Commandment,” targeting more than a dozen Christian pastors across the U.S., whom he accused of misleading followers. He has described his actions as intended to be “heinous,” with no mitigating factors.
Sheafe requested the death penalty on the basis of providing closure to all parties, stating, “What about the victim’s families? What about me? What about my family? We want closure so we can move on with our lives.” He previously expressed a desire for immediate execution, claiming that victims’ families and taxpayers also support it.
Context on Defendant’s Background
The defendant’s father reported that Sheafe became deeply interested in the Old Testament and bore a tattoo with the Hebrew word for God, symbolizing his claimed allegiance. Sheafe maintains he is mentally sound. He has openly discussed his motive and crime in interviews with law enforcement and media outlets.
For more stories on this topic, visit our category page.
