President Donald Trump renewed his demand for Colorado Governor Jared Polis to grant clemency to Tina Peters, a former Mesa County election clerk serving a nine-year sentence for a 2021 voting system security breach. Peters was convicted in August 2024 on seven charges, including four felonies, related to attempts to uncover evidence supporting claims of fraud in the 2020 presidential election. Trump called on Polis to free Peters, highlighting her age and health conditions in posts on social media.
Governor Polis Conditions Clemency on Remorse
Governor Jared Polis acknowledged that Peters’ sentence was severe, particularly given her lack of prior criminal history, but emphasized the need for equitable justice. He noted disparities in sentencing, referencing a former state lawmaker convicted of a similar offense who received probation and community service. Polis has stated he would consider clemency only if Peters demonstrates appropriate contrition and apology, which state officials report she has not shown.
State Officials Oppose Political Pressure on Clemency
Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser, involved in prosecuting Peters, stressed that clemency decisions should be grounded in remorse and rehabilitation rather than political influence. Similarly, U.S. Senator Michael Bennet opposed pardoning Peters, warning against yielding to political pressures that could undermine state governance. Despite Trump’s announcement of a symbolic full pardon last year, such a pardon does not apply to state convictions, as clemency authority resides with the governor.
Federal Funding Dispute Linked to Clemency Pressure
Recently, a federal judge ruled that the U.S. Department of Agriculture threatened to withhold millions in federal funding for Colorado’s SNAP program as possible retribution for the state’s refusal to pardon Peters. The judge described this action as a violation of the Constitution’s Spending Clause. Additionally, allegations surfaced that the Trump administration targeted a climate research lab in Colorado in retaliation for Peters’ imprisonment.
These developments highlight ongoing political and legal tensions surrounding Peters’ conviction and clemency prospects.
For more stories on this topic, visit our category page.
