Harriet Harman has publicly criticized Angela Rayner’s recent high-profile speech that questioned the direction of Sir Keir Starmer’s Labour government, calling it a “negative intervention” lacking constructive proposals. Harman made the remarks during an interview on the Electoral Dysfunction podcast with Sky News political editor Beth Rigby.
Harman Warns Against Criticism Without Solutions
Speaking about Rayner’s address at a campaign event hosted by Mainstream on March 18, Harman acknowledged Rayner’s influence in energizing the Labour Party during opposition. However, she said the speech, which warned that Labour was “running out of time,” failed to offer positive alternatives. “I just don’t think she should be doing this. I think it’s wrong for her and it’s certainly wrong for the party and the government,” Harman said, adding that the approach was similar to that of political opponents such as Nigel Farage and Kemi Badenoch.
Immigration Remarks Also Face Criticism
Harman also challenged Rayner’s dismissal of immigration as an issue, noting its prominence in public opinion polls where it ranks second only to the cost of living. Harman questioned Rayner’s suggestion that imposing stricter immigration controls is “un-British,” urging for clarity on alternative policies. “Is she saying it doesn’t matter that people are concerned about immigration or this is the wrong policy and we should be trying something else?” Harman asked.
The debate over Rayner’s speech highlights ongoing tensions within Labour over party strategy and messaging ahead of future elections.
For more stories on this topic, visit our category page.